A team of researchers at the University
of Innsbruck used proton-transfer-reaction mass
spectrometry to measure a number of sulfides
present in the breath of garlic eaters. Their
work was first reported in The New Scientist in
January 1997:
Science : The good thing
about garlic breath
25 January 1997
From New Scientist Print Edition.
David Bradley
GARLIC has long been considered a natural medicine
and has been shown tolower levels of cholesterol
in the blood, but researchers disagree over the
metabolic mechanisms involved.
Now a team at the University of
Innsbruck in Austria has discovered that the lingering
smell on the breath of garlic-eaters comes not
from the plant itself, but from chemicals in the
blood produced by a change in the body's metabolism.
The researchers suggest that this could be the
secret of garlic's efficacy.
Werner Lindinger and his colleagues
analysed the volatile organic compounds in the
breath of people up to 30 hours after they had
eaten garlic cloves. They found that levels of
most of the strong-smelling sulfides and disulfides,
which are given off by freshly crushed garlic,
fell within a few hours of eating. But three compounds—allyl
methyl sulfide, dimethyl sulfide and acetone—took
much longer to reach their peak levels and were
still present at high levels even after 30 hours.
Lindinger believes that these high
levels were the result of metabolic changes brought
about by the garlic. Acetone is a known degradation
product of numerous fatty compounds in the blood,
including cholesterol.
He points out that the amount of
acetone given off by crushed garlic (10 parts
per billion) is far less than the peak levels
in the breath a day after eating garlic (more
than 5 parts per million) (Journal of Agricultural
and Food Chemistry, vol 44, p 3778).
Analysis of Compounds in Human Breath
after Ingestion of Garlic Using Proton-Transfer-Reaction
Mass Spectrometry
Johann Taucher, Armin Hansel, Alfons
Jordan, and Werner Lindinger*
Institut für Ionenphysik, Leopold
Franzens Universität Innsbruck, Technikerstrasse
25, A 6020 Innsbruck, Austria
Received for review August 27, 1996.
Accepted August 30, 1996.
After ingestion of raw garlic,
the components allyl methyl sulfide (1), allyl
methyl
disulfide (2), diallyl sulfide (3), diallyl disulfide
(4), diallyl trisulfide (7), dimethyl sulfide
(8), and acetone (9) in the breath of a test
person were analyzed over a time period of about
30 h
by means of proton-transfer-reaction mass spectrometry.
While the concentrations of 2-7 reached maxima
shortly after ingestion of garlic and declined
to baseline values within the next 2-3 h, concentrations
of 1, 8, and 9 increased much more slowly and
showed enhanced values even 30 h after garlic
consumption. The strong increase of the concentration
of acetone might be indicative of enhanced metabolism
of serum cholesterol, triglycerides, and total
lipids in the blood stream.
The research by Ricom, Sakai and Lindinger
shows a complex mix of mercaptans and sulfides
present in the breath of garlic eaters at varying
times after ingestion. There is no doubt that
most of the compounds found in the breath samples
are as a result of metabolic activity. Sakai
believes that the prime cause of garlic breath
is the production of mercaptans and claims to
have invented a process which inhibits the metabolic
pathway responsible for their production. Research
from the University of Innsbruck indicated a
mix of persistent sulfides and acetone.
Our research was designed to test the claims
made for Dr Sakai garlic and to that end we
used GC-MS to measure the levels of methyl,
ethyl and propyl mercaptan in food products
made with Dr Sakai garlic and compared the results
to levels found after eating products made with
untreated garlic. Whilst Sakai specifies these
three mercaptans in his patent he also gives
mention to three other compounds - allyl mercaptan,
dimethyl sulfide and allyl methyl sulfide
- and these were also included in our tests.